I lived in Winbig for part of my freshmen year and my entire sophomore year. I lived in Graham for my first semester at Monmouth and that was not the best experience. Once I moved into Winbig, I somehow had ants on the second floor of the building, but regardless, it is the best underclassmen dorm on campus. What really makes your hall is your neighbors and the friends you make, but I would recommend for Winbig for location and cleanliness.